Debit Card vs Credit Card: Which Is More Secure Online? (2024)

Although both debit and credit cards provide easy methods of payment, credit cards have better fraud protection which makes them more secure to use online. Credit card fraud can easily happen through security breaches or cyber attacks that steal your payment card information. It’s important to use the most secure payment method to protect yourself from the damaging effects of credit card fraud.

Continue reading to learn more about the differences between debit and credit cards, what credit card fraud is and which card you should use online.

What Is a Debit Card?

A debit card is a payment card that pulls money from a user’s checking account to make purchases or withdraw cash. Since a debit card is directly linked to your checking account, the amount of money in your account determines how much you can spend with the card. Debit cards reduce the need to carry cash since you have direct access to your money. They are also protected by a Personal Identification Number (PIN), but PINs are not always used for every purchase.

What Is a Credit Card?

Rather than using the money from a linked checking account, a credit card borrows money from a financial institution, allowing the user to make purchases that they’ll pay back in the future with interest. Unlike debit cards, credit cards can incur debt if you don’t repay the financial institutions the money you borrowed from them. Credit cards offer fraud protection that allows consumers to dispute fraudulent charges made on their credit cards.

What Is Credit Card Fraud?

Credit card fraud is when an unauthorized user gains access to either your credit or debit card and uses it to make purchases without your permission. Cybercriminals can get a hold of your payment cards by either stealing your physical card or tricking you into revealing details about your card, such as the card number and expiration date. Once the cybercriminal has access to a payment card, they can steal your money and make purchases that can negatively impact your credit.

Credit card fraud can be scary to deal with as it can leave lasting effects such as damaged credit, debt and even identity theft. A cybercriminal can misuse your credit card to make large purchases that can put you in debt and damage your credit. This can cost you a lot of money and make the application process for future loans difficult.

Depending on how much information a cybercriminal steals, credit card fraud can lead to identity theft in which the cybercriminal can commit crimes under your name and potentially leave you with a criminal record.

It is important to monitor your spending activity and check for any unfamiliar purchases. You should also secure your online financial accounts to prevent cybercriminals from performing account takeover attacks. Most importantly, you need to be careful with your debit and credit card online to avoid credit card fraud. If you notice credit card fraud, you should freeze your credit, contact your card issuer and report the fraud to the FTC.

Which Is More Secure: Debit Card or Credit Card?

Although both debit and credit cards offer fraud protection, credit cards are more secure than debit cards since they offer better protection. If you were to be a victim of credit card fraud, the financial institution would investigate the situation and the responsibility to repay the fraudulent charges should not fall on you. However, with debit card fraud, the money being stolen is directly coming from your bank account. Even if the financial institution investigates, the chances of you regaining your money are unlikely.

Debit CardsCredit Cards

Federal law that protects consumers from unfair billing

Electronic Funds Transfer Act (EFTA)

Fair Credit Billing Act (FCBA)

If lost card reported before any purchases were made on it

Zero liability

Zero liability

If lost card reported and unauthorized purchases were already made on it


If reported within two business days, could be charged $50 for unauthorized purchases.

Afterward, could be charged $500, or the entire amount of the unauthorized purchases.


If reported within 60 days of receiving the account statement with the transaction, zero liability.

Afterwards, could be charged $50 for the unauthorized purchases.

If someone uses your card but doesn’t have the physical card


If the loss is reported within 60 days of receiving the account statement with the transaction, zero liability.

Afterward, liable for the charges.

Zero liability

Should You Use Debit or Credit Online?

You should primarily use your credit card online since it offers better fraud protection and keeps your money safe by using borrowed money. Using your credit card for everyday and major purchases online will help protect your money from getting stolen.

The best way to protect your credit and debit cards online is to only shop on trusted websites and avoid saving your card information to your browser or on the company’s site. You should keep your credit and debit cards in a safe physical location. If you want to store your payment cards online, you should store them in either a password manager or a digital wallet since they both use encryption and MFA to keep your cards secure.

A digital wallet is an online payment tool that securely stores payment information, gift cards, membership cards, transportation tickets and other important financial information. Through an app, digital wallets allow you to make in-person or online purchases without having to carry cash or your payment cards. They provide a secure way to store your debit and credit cards while also making convenient purchases on your smartphone. However, not all online and physical stores support digital wallets.

Using a Password Manager to Store Credit Card Information

The best tool to store your credit and debit cards online is a password manager. A password manager is a tool that securely stores and manages your passwords, but it also stores other information like your credit card numbers, all inside of an encrypted vault. When you store your credit and debit cards in a password manager, they are protected by zero-trust and zero-knowledge encryption that ensures every user needs to verify their identity to access them in your encrypted vault and protects you from security breaches.

Password managers allow users to enable Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA) to add an extra layer of security for their stored debit and credit cards. MFA requires you to provide an additional form of authentication along with your master password before gaining access to your vault. This makes it difficult for cybercriminals to get into your vault, even if your password was compromised.

When you store your debit or credit card in a password manager, you can easily use them on online stores since password managers can autofill your cards on the website. This helps protect your credit and debit cards from cyber attacks such as keyloggers. Keyloggers are a type of malware that can record a user’s keystrokes to gather sensitive information. Password managers protect your cards from keylogging attacks since you avoid typing your card information into the online store.

How Keeper Protects Your Credit Cards

You should be using your credit card over your debit card when spending online to protect yourself from credit card fraud. The best way to store your credit card is with a password manager. Password managers are protected by encryption, MFA and autofill features that prevent cybercriminals from stealing your credit card information. Sign up for a free trial of Keeper Password Manager to start protecting your credit cards online.

Debit Card vs Credit Card: Which Is More Secure Online? (2024)

FAQs

Debit Card vs Credit Card: Which Is More Secure Online? ›

You should primarily use your credit card online since it offers better fraud protection and keeps your money safe by using borrowed money. Using your credit card for everyday and major purchases online will help protect your money from getting stolen.

Is it safer to use credit or debit online? ›

Since credit cards offer fraud liability protections that debit cards do not, meaning online purchases with credit come with fewer risks. So if you're debating debit or credit for online shopping, pick credit for a safer shopping experience.

Do credit cards have more security than debit cards? ›

Paying with a credit card not only provides you with an extra layer of security compared to a debit card, but rewards you with cash-back, redeemable points or travel miles. Some credit cards also have welcome bonuses in addition to other ongoing perks.

Is using a debit card more secure than using a credit card? ›

Key Takeaways. Credit cards give you access to a line of credit issued by a bank, while debit cards deduct money directly from your bank account. Credit cards offer better consumer protections against fraud compared with debit cards linked to a bank account.

Which is safer direct debit or credit card? ›

For debit cards, however, the funds are debited directly from the customer account, limiting the consumer protections available. Direct Debit protection - Direct Debit is typically less susceptible to fraud than credit and debit cards.

How safe is a debit card online? ›

Payments with a debit card are taken instantly from your checking account and shopping online comes with the added risk that your information may be stolen. Using a debit card opens up the possibility that the thief will gain access to the funds in your checking account.

Should I use a debit card for online purchases? ›

But debit cards are not a good way to pay when you shop online. Credit cards are safer to use when you buy things online: You might have a problem with something you buy online. It is easier to get your money back if you use a credit card.

Why use credit card over debit card? ›

Credit cards are safer to carry and use

It may take some time to sort out the resulting mess, but you won't lose any of your money. Debit cards, too, pose a risk. When your credit card is used fraudulently, it's the card issuer that loses money.

How do debit cards get hacked? ›

Debit card fraud can be sophisticated or old-school. Thieves use techniques including: Hacking. When you bank or shop on public Wi-Fi networks, hackers can use keylogging software to capture everything you type, including your name, debit card account number and PIN.

Why do people use debit cards more than credit cards? ›

Using a debit card may prevent you from making large, impulse purchases that you can't afford. They don't charge interest. Since debit card payments take money out of your account right away, you don't accumulate a balance that you have to pay interest on. This is a key difference between a credit card and debit card.

Can someone use my debit card without my PIN? ›

If you don't have proper security measures in place and the criminal obtains your debit card information, they can use it for fraudulent online or over-the-phone transactions. These types of transactions don't require a PIN or signature, making the criminal's job easier.

What is the major disadvantage of using a debit card? ›

Some ATMs will charge withdrawal fees, and if you use more than the agreed overdraft limit then the fees tend to be much greater than those incurred by credit card usage. Another disadvantage of debit cards is the fact that they have limited funds, which can slow down business.

Can I trust Amazon with my debit card? ›

Amazon follows the Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS) when handling card data, safeguarding the privacy and security of users' payment and transaction information.

Am I protected if I pay by credit card? ›

Credit card payment protection

This means that if there's an issue with the product you've bought or the company you've bought from goes into administration, the credit card company has equal responsibility to make sure you're not left out of pocket.

Is it safe to use a credit card online? ›

By and large, credit cards are easily the most secure and safe payment method to use when you shop online. Credit cards use online security features like encryption and fraud monitoring to keep your accounts and personal information safe.

Is paying with PayPal safer than debit card? ›

Key takeaways

PayPal and credit cards both offer protection when shopping online. PayPal protects shoppers if items go missing or arrive damaged. Using PayPal or a credit card is safer than using your debit card. It's still important to keep your PayPal account secure.

Is it safe to give debit card number and CVV online? ›

It's generally safe to enter a debit card number and CVV online on reputable and trustworthy websites. However, it's good practice to exercise caution when online shopping — there's always a risk of financial information being compromised.

What are the risks of using a credit card online? ›

Top 5 Security Risks in Credit Card Payments (And How to Conquer Them)
  • Employee Error. You know how important it is to invest in a secure network. ...
  • Improperly Stored Credit Card Information. ...
  • Credit Card Fraud. ...
  • Outdated System Software. ...
  • POS Skimming.

Should you use a credit card for online shopping? ›

Online Purchases

Credit card transactions are typically more easily traced online than if you use debit, money orders or checks. These cards often provide a certain amount of coverage for fraudulent purchases, which can really help cardholders if their credit card information happens to fall into the wrong hands.

When should you use a debit card instead of a credit card? ›

If you find yourself struggling to pay off your credit card, using a debit card may be a better way to manage overspending. "If you have credit card debt, then putting routine purchases on a debit card would make sense in order to avoid going deeper into debt.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Margart Wisoky

Last Updated:

Views: 5421

Rating: 4.8 / 5 (58 voted)

Reviews: 81% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Margart Wisoky

Birthday: 1993-05-13

Address: 2113 Abernathy Knoll, New Tamerafurt, CT 66893-2169

Phone: +25815234346805

Job: Central Developer

Hobby: Machining, Pottery, Rafting, Cosplaying, Jogging, Taekwondo, Scouting

Introduction: My name is Margart Wisoky, I am a gorgeous, shiny, successful, beautiful, adventurous, excited, pleasant person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.